When so many charlatans pose as big holy Kabbalists, it is easy to understand why some people are wary of Kabbalah. History has had its fair share of imposters — unscrupulous people with no conscience who tricked the masses into becoming a part of their cult and/ or swindled them out of their money.
What is more, there is so much controversy and misinformation about Kabbalah that it is even difficult to broach the subject.
To many the teachings of Kabbalah may sound as if they contradict the Torah or the teachings of the sages, but this is not so.
The truth is that real Kabbalah is the highest form of wisdom available. And because it is so high, one cannot grasp it entirely until one learns all of its parts.
But one might perceive Kabbalah as antithetical to Torah because one’s mind is still in a state of constriction and has not attained its true Light. When true Light is attained, one begins to see the beauty and depth of the Torah and Talmud. At that point, one’s life can be analyzed in Kabbalah’s system of Sephirot. Then, through personal rectifications, one can chart a path to ascension. Finally, one begins to see there’s actually no difference between Halacha and Kabbalah: it’s all part of the same whole.
But until then, everything seems pitch black, because nothing makes sense.
In any case, whether you are a beginner or advanced student, there are a few things you need to know when dealing with people who claim to know a lot about Kabbalah.
Here are five truths that are unchangeable and anyone who contradicts them can be readily branded an impostor or charlatan. Keep these truths in mind when talking with people about Kabbalah:
1. Kabbalah is based on the Torah and Talmud
Many attempts to dissociate Kabbalah from traditional Judish life have been made. But all these attempts are distortions and confusion. In the end, to do so makes no sense because the only real truth in the world emanates from Torah, from which every other truth, including from secular sciences emerges.
This is unsurprising since the chain of Kabbalah has extended uninterrupted from Adam HaRishon to the Arizal and the Rashash. After that many others began to usurp the Light of Kabbalah and mix in their own reasonings and religion.
They claim they have a better way of understanding its wisdom but it is fake, and their arguments are like a castle of cards that falls down with the slightest touch.
Never forget: the great Prophets, Tannaim, Amoraim, Geonim, Rishonim and Acharonim, all knew Kabbalah very well because they used its wisdom, one way or another, to come to their chiddushim (novellae) or psak (legal ruling).
2. Kabbalah is about serving and coming closer to Hashem
Since Kabbalah explains the attributes of Hashem, by definition, knowing more Kabbalah should make you more like the Creator. When that happens, you come closer to Him and become a better person.
When charlatans complain that you did not give charity to them because you cannot appreciate their exalted holiness and mastery of Kabbalah, then that means their holiness is not so exalted and they do not know Kabbalah at all.
One can know about a lot of things, including Kabbalah, but if this wisdom does not transform you, then it is worthless or even worse. Our sages say that whoever hears Torah but does not internalize it and reflect it in action and character, it would have been better to have not been born.
Ultimately, the main sign that one truly knows Kabbalah is to see Torah written on the heart with a character that exhibits compassion, kindness, patience, forgiveness, gentleness, humbleness, and so on.
3. The path of Kabbalah demands purity, holiness, and humility
Studying Kabbalah is a huge responsibility and it demands a higher standard of religious observance. But this is the outer facet of it. The inner facet is that as the wisdom of Kabbalah transforms you, you become less attached to the material world.
This generates a certain tension. On one hand, the Light of Kabbalah pulls you upwards, but if you fight it by giving free reign to your material desires, then you can actually feed this Light to the Sitra Achra (the side of impurity). Feeding the Sitra Achra whether by sinning or giving in to your desires causes it to become stronger and gives it the opening it needs to hurt you.
So do you work and go to the mikvah as much as you can. Usually, people in this path go every day, once in the morning before the morning Shacharit prayers. Remember to be conscious when you eat to eat only as much as you actually need. Also, one should not overindulge in sleep and marital relations.
If you have to work, work. But remember, it is not a mitzvah to work 10 hours every day. Remember that work is a curse and that we only work in order to get money to be able to study Torah and serve Hashem, not the other way around. Ideally as a person grows in his occupation, he should need less work and be more focused on self-refining and study.
4. Knowing everything before understanding anything
Kabbalah is compared to the sense of sight because one attains its knowledge by knowing all the parts. Consider one who describes a car to his friend.
What is the chance his friend will paint the exact car he saw? Obviously 0%, because nothing substitutes true seeing, or rather, true experiencing. Seeing is parallel to Wisdom (Chokhmah) while speech, the written language, is parallel to Understanding (Binah).
The differences are obvious. Speech takes time to convey the message. One needs to hear it entirely (or guess it), analyze it and only then understand.
Seeing is instantaneous. One who sees a car or a friend immediately knows a lot without thinking!
Likewise, in order to acquire wisdom, a person needs to toil to understand the concepts through verbal language. Understanding, in this case, precedes wisdom. Similarly, while we can recognize a car, we cannot understand its inner workings without studying.
So, while one can grasp the laws of Tallit, Tefillin and Shabbat on their own, one cannot have an idea of what Kabbalah is all about without thoroughly learning all of its concepts.
5. The light of Kabbalah has no equal
No Jew in the world can reach his full Tikkun (fix, repair) without the Inner Torah, no matter how much of the other parts of Torah he studies. The Arizal already said that one who does not study this wisdom is forced by Heaven to reincarnate in order to get his Tikkun.
True, one can fulfill this requirement by studying Chassidut and that is the general consensus among Kabbalists. People who cannot understand the writings of the Arizal and the Rashash can fulfill their obligation to study the Sod by studying Chassidut, which in essence is the wisdom of Kabbalah clothed in lower garments so everyone can understand.
But do not think you can fulfill this obligation by studying Halacha, Mishnah, Gemara or even Midrashim! This also includes perushim (explanations) on the Torah by any other Rabbi, great as he may be.
The Light of Kabbalah is irreplaceable and happy is one who internalizes it.
True, one can fulfill this requirement by studying Chassidut and that is the general consensus among Kabbalists. People who cannot understand the writings of the Arizal and the Rashash can fulfill their obligation to study the Sod by studying Chassidut, which in essence is the wisdom of Kabbalah clothed in lower garments so everyone can understand.
But do not think you can fulfill this obligation by studying Halacha, Mishnah, Gemara or even Midrashim! This also includes perushim (explanations) on the Torah by any other Rabbi, great as he may be.
The Light of Kabbalah is irreplaceable and happy is one who internalizes it.
Concluding remarks
Kabbalah is the inner wisdom of the Torah. If the Torah contains all the “code” of Creation, Kabbalah explains how to interpret the code. One does not program a computer without learning thoroughly what each syntax or code does and how it is supposed to be written.
Yet, one needs care because this is very much the precious crown jewel that HaShem bestowed on the world. One who abuses this knowledge will surely have to pay a high price.
To this end, our mission and purpose of life is to learn deeply about Hashem and connect to Him in a way like no other.
Rabbi Yaakov Avraham Shepherd is the head of Yeshivas HaMekubalim Nefesh HaChaim on Mount Zion, Jerusalem, and Head Kabbalist at King David Kabbalah. He has also been teaching at Diaspora Yeshiva for over 15 years, where he has taught Chumash, Navi, Gemara, Shulchan Aruch and more, in English and Hebrew. More…

